Creating a positive culture and
identity for schools in Australia
On the 9th of July 2012 the Sydney morning herald (http://www.smh.com.au/opinion/political-news/education-takes-a-dramatic-new-course-20120709-21rti.html) certified that
dance, drama, media arts, music and visual arts will be studied by Australian
students and integrated into schools up until year 10. The article emphasised
the importance of the new policy in education to provide an adequate and
sustainable arts program in schools which the students will benefit from for
their future prospects. The article also explains that having the arts apart of
the curriculum will be believed to cause a positive impact in helping students
develop or reshape their sense of identity. New forms of expression can create
an identity politics as students will inherit certain practises through the
arts which might be against their cultural markers or what they identify
themselves with. In the reading sociology on culture’ (hall, Neitz &
bettani 2003) it is demonstrated that an identity politics is created through
music, dress and slang, as through the use of our body’s and the actions
created can negate people’s sense of identity through new expressions and way
of life. For example drama creates different realities in which students can
express themselves in many ways through their emotions, gestures, movement and
language, this gives a chance for them to experience fulfilment and find their
true self’s within their false identity of the character that they play; just
as explained in the sociology on culture reading that males discover their
gender identity by not being female in the absence of their fatherly figure
(hall, Neitz & bettani 2003 p. 18). This therefore correlates with the
views displayed in the news article as the education minister’s argument is
that the arts will ultimately enhance creativity and help develop a sense of
identity and have a positive influence on Australia’s culture. However the students can be conflicted in
which identity they associate themselves with. From an educative perspective
the news article has given reliable statistics to confirm that the arts is in
fact a positive influence in education as it has improved school attendance for
the participants and has increased motivation and class participation. In
society rules and cultural aspects can dictate the way of life and hence impact
to ones identity, through education policy of the arts being made compulsory
till year 10 provides a 4 year permanent state in which the students will adapt
to new creative practises which will decrease their laziness and improve their
social skills, ability to think critically and diligently and to find their
sense of self. However in saying this the arts can provide a period where students
will develop attributes or interests which can alter their future identity or
interfere with the symbols of the present one creating an identity politics in
where they either conform or reject. The arts are a crucial aspect of the
education system and although it might not be suitable for everyone can
positively provide even a small since of self identity even impacting them
culturally through either dressing or not dressing, acting or not acting in a
certain way in everyday life.
The Sydney Morning Herald , 9th of July 2012, “Education
takes a dramatic new course”: http://www.smh.com.au/opinion/political-news/education-takes-a-dramatic-new-course-20120709-21rti.html
Hall, J.R, Neitz, M.J & Battani, M. (2003). Sociology on culture. London. Chapter 2:
Culture, self and society
Priscilla Younes
A LOT of questions are raised when read this. I understand that there is a positive association between identity and the creative and performing arts but what caught my eye is “although it might not be suitable for everyone it can positively provide even a small (I think there is a word missing which I am assuming along the lines of contribution…)”
ReplyDeleteThe issue is that these subjects are to be made compulsory until year10 (which I would have no objection against because I loved these subjects). I’m not sure if its changed but these subjects currently have a specific hours requirement to fulfill in order to attain the yr 10 school certificate, however that no longer exists…
What I am trying to say is that isn’t the compulsory x hours currently required for these CAPA subjects enough for students to develop that little bit their identity?
What happens if some students are unable to develop their sense of identity but is stuck in the course because they unable to change? What is the opportunity cost of making these courses compulsory; one less elective to chose from in order to accommodate time for these subjects?
I suppose the bulk of my questions arise from friends who find their identity through subjects like woodwork, IPT and cooking, and had a terrible time doing VA. What would happen to their sense of identity if those elective subjects were taken away from them because CAPA was compulsory?
Dear Priscilla,
ReplyDeleteYou make a clear link between the arts and identity. What is less clear is how this creates an 'identity politics'. You may need to revisit this post to make this link more substantial - and to see what are the limits and possibilities of an identity politics.
Regards,
Kal